NYC Food Gifts That Ship: Bagels, Pastrami and Cheesecake

These are New York delis, bagel shops, pizzerias and bakeries whose food ships nationwide through Goldbelly. Each pick links to its Goldbelly page, where the price, contents and storage notes were checked on Nov. 2, 2026. None of these product pages lists a holiday delivery cutoff, so check the delivery date at checkout before counting on a Thanksgiving or Christmas arrival.

Russ & Daughters ships a Best of NY Box ($99.00) with half a pound of Gaspe Nova smoked salmon, six assorted bagels, half a pound of plain cream cheese and a chocolate babka. It serves 6, and the salmon keeps 7-10 days refrigerated.

Ess-a-Bagel sends The Lox Box Special ($209.95) for a crowd: 12 bagels, a pound of cream cheese and 2 lbs of nova, serving 12. Capers and chives aren't included.

2nd Ave Deli ships a Whole Kosher Pastrami Kit for 8-10 ($269.95): a whole pastrami of about 4-4.5 lbs, a quart of sour and half-sour pickles, a loaf of rye, Russian dressing and mustard. It is certified kosher.

Lombardi's Pizza ships a New York-Style Pizza 4 Pack ($129.95) of 12-inch Margherita or Pepperoni pies, with the pepperoni packed on the side. The pizzas come with ice packs and keep 3 days in the fridge or a month frozen.

Di Fara Pizza in Brooklyn ships a Neapolitan Pizza 2 Pack ($89.95) of 12-inch pies, chosen from 11 options including Classic Cheese, Pepperoni, White and Three Cheese Vodka Tomato. They ship frozen with dry ice and may arrive thawed; the page says they can be refrozen.

Junior's of Brooklyn ships its Original Cheesecake in an 8-inch size ($82.95) that serves 12-14. It arrives frozen with dry ice; thaw it overnight in the fridge, then 3-4 hours on the counter.

Magnolia Bakery sends Classic Banana Pudding as a 6 pack ($74.95) of roughly 12 oz cups, serving 10-12. Refrigerate on arrival and eat within 48 hours; don't freeze it.

Levain Bakery ships its Signature Cookie Assortment ($32.95) of 6 oz cookies in Chocolate Chip Walnut, Dark Chocolate Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin and Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip, in packs of 4, 8 or 12.

Visiting? Russ & Daughters is at 179 E Houston St on the Lower East Side, where you take a number at the counter. Lombardi's is at 30 Spring St in Nolita, and Levain's first bakery is on W. 74th Street on the Upper West Side.